A quartet of Borzage
Reviewer: James van Maanen
Rating (out of 5):
Under consideration
Liliom (Disc 8 of 12): ***
Bad Girl (Disc 10) ****
After Tomorrow ***½
Young America ***½ (Both Disc 11)
If you think the catch-phrase "So many movies, so little time" has meaning when you're young, I can only advise you: Just wait. With this in mind, I decided to tackle only four of the thirteen films in the new Murnau, Borzage and Fox Box Set from Fox--which offers several from each director plus a documentary about the two men and their history with the Fox studio.
Oddly enough, the least of the four is probably the best-known property in the series: Liliom (1930) -- from the Ferenc Molnár stage play, which has been filmed a half dozen times (two of these for TV and once as Rodgers & Hammerstein musical Carousel). Liliom is the title character, a carnival
barker/ladies' man (Charles Farrell) who falls in sort-of love with a young serving girl, Julie (Rose Hobart). The story is simple in the extreme, and for all of director Frank Borzage's vaunted skills in serving up tasty melodrama while drawing good performances from his cast, the film has a stagy look and feel. The dialog is slow and the filmmaking obvious,
although it is interesting to see what kind of "special effects" were available back in the day, and there is one choice political line about the name of a particular train. Farrell and Hobart do what they can, as does the supporting cast, and the cinematography is good (Fox and its collaborators have done a wonderful job of obtaining and then burnishing the best remaining prints, so these four transfers are pretty spectacular).
